Research has challenged the assumption that personality pathology is egosyntonic. The present study used correlational analysis, mean comparisons, and structural equation modeling in a community sample (n = 401) to examine relations between self-rated maladaptive personality and liking of maladaptive traits in self and others as well as meta-perception of personality pathology (i.e., how likable participants believe others find maladaptive traits). In general, individuals with higher self-rated maladaptive traits provided higher ratings of the likability of these traits in themselves and others. However, as hypothesized, comparison of liking ratings for high scorers and the rest of the sample revealed that individuals who score highly on most pathological personality traits do not “like” these traits (or rate others as “liking” them) but simply dislike them less. Results support a dimensional view of egosyntonicity.